How Uninsured Motorist Claims Work in Tennessee

Auto Insurance · Tennessee Drivers

About one in five Tennessee drivers on the road has no auto insurance, according to the most recent state-by-state estimate from the Insurance Research Council. That means the question is not only whether you carry uninsured motorist coverage, but what actually happens when you need to use it. This guide walks through how an uninsured motorist claim works in Tennessee from start to finish: what the coverage pays, how a hit-and-run is handled, which policy pays first when you are in someone else’s car, how the other driver’s insurance is subtracted, and the small choices on your application that make a big difference later.

The short version: Tennessee law puts uninsured motorist coverage on every auto liability policy at the same limits as your bodily injury liability coverage, unless the named insured rejects it or chooses lower limits in writing. The coverage pays for your injuries when the driver who caused the crash has no insurance, has too little insurance, or cannot be identified. Hit-and-run claims carry extra proof requirements, damage to your car is a separate option with its own deductible rules, and an insurance company may not raise your rate or cancel your coverage solely because it paid an uninsured motorist claim.

Why Uninsured Drivers Are a Bigger Issue in Tennessee

The Insurance Research Council, a nonprofit research organization funded by the insurance industry, estimates the share of uninsured drivers in each state by comparing how often people file claims for injuries caused by uninsured drivers against how often they file claims against insured drivers. In its estimate for 2023, published by the Insurance Information Institute, Tennessee came in at 21.3 percent, which ranked fifth highest in the country. Only Mississippi, New Mexico, the District of Columbia, and Michigan ranked higher. Missouri, which ranked sixth, was close behind at 20.7 percent, and Texas sat at 14.5 percent.

In practical terms, if you are hit by another driver in Tennessee, there is a real chance that the person who caused the crash cannot pay for your medical bills. Even drivers who do carry insurance often buy only the state minimum of $25,000 for injury to one person, $50,000 for injuries to two or more people, and $25,000 for property damage, which our guide to Tennessee auto and home insurance rules explains in detail. A single emergency room visit followed by surgery and several weeks of missed work can easily cost more than $25,000. Uninsured motorist coverage is the part of your own policy designed to fill that gap.

What Uninsured Motorist Coverage Pays For

Uninsured motorist coverage is insurance you buy to protect yourself from other drivers. Under Tennessee Code section 56-7-1201, it covers people insured under your policy who are “legally entitled to recover compensatory damages” from the owner or driver of an uninsured vehicle because of bodily injury, sickness, disease, or death. Compensatory damages are the amounts a court would award to make you whole, which usually include medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. In plain words, your own insurance company steps into the shoes of the at-fault driver who should have paid you but cannot.

Two points are worth understanding before a claim ever happens. First, the coverage only pays what the other driver would have owed you. If the crash was mostly your fault, the claim is handled the same way a claim against the other driver would be, and fault still matters. Second, the bodily injury portion covers injuries to people, not damage to your car. Damage to your vehicle falls under a separate option called uninsured motorist property damage coverage, or under your collision coverage, which is explained further below.

Underinsured drivers are included in the Tennessee definition

Many people assume uninsured motorist coverage only helps when the other driver has no insurance at all. In Tennessee, the definition is broader. Tennessee Code section 56-7-1202 defines an “uninsured motor vehicle” as one where the total liability insurance available to you is less than your own uninsured motorist limits. That means a driver who carries only the state minimum can count as uninsured for your claim if your uninsured motorist limits are higher. This is one of the strongest reasons to keep your uninsured motorist limits equal to your liability limits rather than cutting them to the minimum.

How the other driver’s insurance is subtracted

Tennessee uses what insurance professionals call an offset approach. Section 56-7-1201 says your insurance company’s limit for an uninsured motorist claim is your coverage amount minus the limits collectible under the other driver’s liability insurance and any other primary uninsured motorist policies that apply. Here is an illustration of the math, not a quote or a promise of any claim result.

Situation What it means for your claim
Your uninsured motorist limit is $100,000 per person, and the at-fault driver carries the $25,000 state minimum. The at-fault driver’s company pays up to its $25,000 limit. Your own uninsured motorist coverage can then pay up to $75,000 more, for a total of up to $100,000 if your damages reach that amount.
Your uninsured motorist limit is $25,000 per person, and the at-fault driver carries $25,000. Because the other driver’s limit equals yours, the other vehicle does not meet the Tennessee definition of uninsured, and your uninsured motorist coverage would not add anything.
Your uninsured motorist limit is $100,000 per person, and the at-fault driver has no insurance. Your uninsured motorist coverage can pay up to the full $100,000 per person for damages the other driver legally owes you.

Why this matters: if you reduce your uninsured motorist limits to the state minimum to save money, the coverage may do almost nothing in the most common situation, which is being hurt by a driver who carries only the minimum. Keeping your uninsured motorist limits equal to your liability limits is what makes the offset work in your favor.

Hit-and-Run Crashes Have Extra Rules

When the driver who hit you drives away and is never identified, your uninsured motorist coverage can still apply, but Tennessee sets specific conditions in section 56-7-1201. You must meet each of the following for the claim to be paid.

  1. Proof that the other vehicle existed. Either there must have been actual physical contact between the unknown vehicle and you or your property, or the existence of the unknown driver must be proven by clear and convincing evidence that comes from someone other than the people riding in your car. A phantom vehicle that ran you off the road without touching you is covered only if an independent witness or similar evidence backs up what happened.
  2. A timely police report. You, or someone acting for you, must report the accident to the appropriate law enforcement agency within a reasonable time after it happens. Calling the police from the scene, or as soon as you are able to, protects your claim.
  3. Reasonable effort to identify the driver. You must not have been careless in failing to find out who the other driver or vehicle owner was at the time of the accident. If the driver stopped, you could not get their information, and you never asked, that can create problems.

Practical steps help with all three. Take photographs of any paint transfer or damage that shows contact, write down a license plate number if you saw even part of it, collect names and phone numbers of witnesses who were not in your car, and ask nearby businesses whether they have security camera footage before it is recorded over.

When the other driver simply never proves insurance

Sometimes the other driver is identified but does not respond, and it is unclear whether they had insurance. Tennessee’s Financial Responsibility Law requires drivers involved in certain crashes to file forms with the Tennessee Department of Safety. Section 56-7-1201 says that if the at-fault driver fails to file those forms within 90 days of the accident, the law presumes the driver was uninsured, unless evidence shows otherwise. After the 90 days, a certified statement showing whether the forms were filed can be requested for a fee. That presumption can help move a stalled claim forward.

Damage to Your Car Is a Separate Choice

The bodily injury part of uninsured motorist coverage does not fix your car. For that, Tennessee requires insurance companies to give every person who buys uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage an opportunity to add uninsured motorist property damage coverage. Property damage here means damage to the insured vehicle, or to property you own that was inside the vehicle at the time.

The $200 deductible

By law, uninsured motorist property damage coverage applies to losses above $200. The deductible is waived when the same insurance company carries both your collision coverage and your uninsured motorist property damage coverage, and the other driver has been positively identified and is solely at fault.

The limit

An insurance company is not required to offer more uninsured motorist property damage coverage than the property damage liability limit you bought. If you carry $25,000 of property damage liability, that is typically the most you could choose for this coverage.

Rejecting it

Once the coverage has been offered and you have rejected it in writing, the company does not have to offer it again at renewal or when you swap vehicles, unless you ask for it in writing or a new application is submitted.

How collision compares

Collision coverage repairs your car no matter who caused the crash, but usually with a higher deductible. Our article on comprehensive and collision coverage in Tennessee explains how the two physical damage coverages work.

If you drive an older car without collision coverage, uninsured motorist property damage coverage can be an inexpensive way to get your car repaired when an identified uninsured driver hits you. If you already carry collision coverage with the same company, it can still help because of the deductible waiver described above. If you are weighing which coverages to keep on an older vehicle, our comparison of liability and full coverage in Tennessee walks through the tradeoffs.

Which Policy Pays When You Are Not in Your Own Car

Tennessee sets a priority order for which uninsured motorist coverage applies, and it also limits stacking. Stacking means adding the uninsured motorist limits from several vehicles or policies together to create a larger total. The rules in section 56-7-1201 work like this.

  • If you are a pedestrian or on a bicycle and not in any vehicle, the policy under which you are insured that has the highest uninsured motorist limits applies, and no other uninsured motorist coverage applies.
  • If you are driving or riding in a vehicle you own, only the uninsured motorist limits on that vehicle apply. Your limits do not increase because you insure several vehicles, whether on one policy or several policies.
  • If you are riding in a vehicle you do not own, such as a friend’s car, a coworker’s truck, or a rideshare, the uninsured motorist coverage on that vehicle pays first. If that coverage runs out, a policy on which you are a named insured pays next as excess coverage, and if that is exhausted, a policy that covers you in some other way, such as a relative’s policy in your household, can apply after that. In every case, your total recovery cannot exceed the highest single uninsured motorist limit among those policies.

This is one reason it is wise to know what your friends’ and family members’ policies carry when you regularly ride with them, and why your own limits matter even when you are a passenger. If you rent cars when traveling, our article on whether auto insurance covers rental cars covers how your own policy follows you.

Rejecting or Lowering the Coverage: Read Before You Sign

The default under Tennessee law is that your uninsured motorist limits equal your bodily injury liability limits. To have less, the named insured, meaning the person named on the declarations page as the policyholder, or that person’s legal representative, must reject the coverage in writing or select lower limits in writing. The lower limits cannot go below the state financial responsibility minimum. The Tennessee Supreme Court has held that signing an application that shows lower uninsured motorist limits can satisfy the writing requirement, even if a separate confirmation box was not initialed, so it is important to read every page of an application before you sign it, including electronic signatures.

Several rules make that one signature last a long time:

  • The rejection or lower selection binds everyone insured under the policy, including your spouse and teenage drivers, even though only the named insured signed it.
  • The signed document is treated as part of the policy whether or not it is physically attached.
  • If you renew, reinstate, or replace the policy with the same company, or swap vehicles, the rejection carries forward unless you ask for the coverage back in writing. A brand new application starts the process over.

If you are not sure what you chose years ago, look at the uninsured motorist line on your current declarations page. If it shows a lower limit than your liability coverage or shows no coverage, you can ask your agent to add or raise it in writing. Our guide to how much car insurance to carry in Tennessee can help you decide what liability and uninsured motorist limits fit your household.

What Uninsured Motorist Coverage Does Not Include

Understanding the limits of the coverage helps you avoid surprises. Under section 56-7-1202, the following are not considered uninsured motor vehicles for this coverage:

  • A vehicle insured under the liability coverage of the same policy, which generally means you cannot use your own uninsured motorist coverage against another car on your own policy.
  • A vehicle owned by, or furnished for the regular use of, you or a spouse or relative living in your household.
  • A vehicle that is self-insured under the Tennessee Financial Responsibility Law or a similar law, such as some large company fleets.
  • A vehicle designed mainly for use off public roads, such as many all-terrain vehicles, except while it is being legally operated on a public road.
  • A vehicle while it is located for use as a premises, such as a parked trailer being used as an office.

It is also important to know that Tennessee law says an excess or umbrella policy does not have to provide uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage. Many umbrella policies, which are extra liability policies that sit on top of your auto and home coverage, protect you when you injure someone else but do not add protection when an uninsured driver injures you. If you carry or are considering an umbrella, ask whether it includes uninsured motorist coverage. Our article on who needs umbrella insurance explains how those policies work.

Will Filing an Uninsured Motorist Claim Raise My Rate?

Tennessee gives drivers a specific protection here. Section 56-7-1201 says an insurance company may not increase your auto insurance rate or premium, or cancel your coverage, solely because it paid a claim under your uninsured motorist coverage. Your rate can still change for other reasons, such as overall rate changes approved for all customers, a new vehicle, or a change in drivers, but the uninsured motorist claim payment by itself cannot be the reason. If you are looking for legitimate ways to lower your premium instead, our list of car insurance discounts in Tennessee is a good place to start.

Step-by-Step: What to Do After a Crash With an Uninsured Driver

  1. Get medical care first. Your health comes first, and medical records also document your injuries for the claim.
  2. Call law enforcement. A police report is essential, and for a hit-and-run it is legally required for an uninsured motorist claim to be paid.
  3. Collect information. Get the other driver’s name, phone number, license plate, vehicle description, and any insurance card they show you. Photograph the scene, the vehicles, and any visible injuries.
  4. Find independent witnesses. Witnesses who were not in your car carry special weight under the Tennessee hit-and-run rules.
  5. Notify your own insurance company promptly. Tell them you may need to use uninsured motorist coverage. Your policy will list notice and cooperation requirements, so follow them closely.
  6. Keep records of every cost. Save medical bills, receipts, pay stubs showing missed work, and repair estimates.
  7. Review your declarations page. Confirm your uninsured motorist bodily injury limits, whether you have uninsured motorist property damage coverage, and whether you carry collision coverage.
  8. Ask for help when injuries are serious. Claims involving significant injuries or disputed fault can become complex, and some people choose to speak with an attorney about their rights and deadlines.

How to Choose Your Tennessee Uninsured Motorist Limits

There is no single right answer, but a few guidelines hold for most households. Matching your uninsured motorist limits to your liability limits keeps the coverage meaningful, especially because of the offset rule. If you have health insurance, it may pay some medical bills, but it usually will not replace lost wages or pay for pain and suffering, and it may have high deductibles. If you have a long commute, ride often with others, or have young drivers in the house, the chance of needing this coverage rises. The added cost of keeping uninsured motorist coverage at the same limits as your liability coverage is often modest compared with the protection it provides, and many customers save significantly overall when an independent agent shops their policy across multiple companies.

Freedom Insurance Group is an independent agency with an office in Knoxville, so we can compare how several companies price uninsured motorist and property damage options side by side. You can browse our Tennessee auto insurance city pages, visit our Knoxville office on Ellington Way, or start a free auto insurance quote.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is uninsured motorist coverage required in Tennessee?

It is included on every Tennessee auto liability policy by default at limits equal to your bodily injury liability limits. The named insured can reject it entirely or choose lower limits, but only in writing, and lower limits cannot go below the state minimum.

Does uninsured motorist coverage pay if the other driver has some insurance?

It can. Tennessee treats a vehicle as uninsured for your claim when the other driver’s available liability insurance is less than your uninsured motorist limits. Your coverage then pays the difference, up to your limit, after the other driver’s limit is subtracted.

Can I add up uninsured motorist limits from several cars?

Generally no. Tennessee law says your uninsured motorist limits do not increase because you insure multiple vehicles, and when more than one policy could apply, the total you can receive is capped at the highest single limit available.

Does my uninsured motorist coverage fix my car?

Not the bodily injury part. You need uninsured motorist property damage coverage, which applies above a $200 deductible that can be waived in some situations, or collision coverage, which pays regardless of fault minus your collision deductible.

Is a hit-and-run covered?

It can be, if there was physical contact with the unknown vehicle or clear and convincing evidence from someone outside your car, the accident was reported to police within a reasonable time, and you were not careless in failing to identify the other driver.

Can an independent agent help me review my coverage?

Yes. An independent agent can read your declarations page with you, explain whether you rejected or lowered uninsured motorist coverage in the past, and compare options from several companies. You can request a quote from Freedom Insurance Group at any time.